The Difference Between Subcontractors and Employees?

Business owners often face a common dilemma—should I hire this worker as a subcontractor or an employee? The distinction may seem subtle, but misclassifying a worker can lead to serious legal consequences and tax penalties. Understanding the key differences between subcontractors and employees is crucial for classifying workers properly and structuring your business relationships appropriately from the start.

Defining Subcontractors and Employees

A subcontractor is an independent contractor who is hired on a project or contract basis to complete specific tasks for a company. Common examples include freelancers, consultants, and outsourced services.

In contrast, an employee works directly for a business and is on the company payroll. The employer provides ongoing work assignments, pays salaries and wages, and takes care of taxes, benefits, and other employment costs.

There is no absolute definition that draws a clear line between subcontractors and employees in all cases. Generally, subcontractors retain independence and operate separate businesses, while employees are integral parts of a company’s operations. Misclassifying workers by labeling employees as subcontractors is illegal in most jurisdictions.

Key Differences

Control of work process - Subcontractors decide when, where, and how they complete contracted work. Employees work under a company’s direction regarding tasks, hours, and other details.

Continuing relationship - Subcontracting involves short-term, project-focused dealings. Employee relationships represent the company’s ongoing operations.

Worker independence - Subcontractors maintain independence and often have multiple clients. Employees perform work dictated by the employer.

Compensation method - Subcontractors submit invoices and are paid per project, deliverable, service performed, etc. Employees earn consistent compensation like salaries, hourly wages, overtime pay, etc.

Provision of tools/materials - Subcontractors generally supply their own tools, materials, training, and other business elements needed to complete work for clients. Employees rely on materials and equipment provided by the employer.

Tax treatment - Companies are not responsible for subcontractor taxes, payroll, insurance, etc. Employers are required to withhold taxes, pay payroll taxes, and handle other wage obligations.

Benefits eligibility - Subcontractors do not qualify for typical employee benefits like health insurance plans, retirement accounts, paid leave, etc. These standard benefits apply to employee classifications only.

Right to works for others - Subcontractors can provide services to multiple clients. Employees work solely for the hiring company.

Liability & risk - Subcontractors shoulder professional liability and business risks themselves. Employers are liable for risks associated with employees conducting work.

Why Proper Classification Matters

Federal and state laws dictate how subcontractors and employees should be treated in areas like taxes, insurance, antidiscrimination protections, expense reimbursements, overtime eligibility, and more. Misclassifying workers can leave businesses exposed in multiple ways:

Tax fines - Payroll tax violations due to 1099 subcontractors who should be W-2 employees often trigger IRS penalties. Some estimates indicate U.S. employers misclassify millions of workers.

Benefits lawsuits - Denying rightful employees standard benefits could prompt legal disputes over issues like health coverage, retirement contributions, leave eligibility, etc.

FLSA violations - Employees misclassified as subcontractors lose Fair Labor Standards Act rights like minimum wages and overtime pay requirements, prompting U.S. Department of Labor action.

Workers’ compensation issues - Workplace injuries can spur investigations into subcontractors who legally qualify as employees entitled to workers’ compensation benefits.

Reclassification audits - State labor departments increasingly conduct audits to identify misclassification, hitting employers who falsely label employees as subcontractors with substantial back costs for unpaid taxes, unemployment insurance, lost wages, and other obligations.

Reputational damage - Lawsuits and major penalties due to subcontractor misclassification generate bad publicity and damaged trust in the employment community.

Clearly defining work relationships is crucial not just for legal compliance but also for operational efficiency, cost control, risk reduction, stable growth planning, and maintaining positive work culture. Taking time to properly designate workers by role and integrate appropriate employment practices clears ambiguity before it becomes a costly problem. The legal, financial, and human impacts make worker classification an essential focus area for any business owner.

Interested in Learning More - Feel free to book an appointment on Calendly here.